Dolphins vs Bills: Bills Win 31–21 on Thursday Night Football — Full Recap, Tyreek Hill Stats & Player Box

Dolphins vs Bills: Buffalo survives Miami 31–21 on Thursday Night Football. Read the full Dolphins vs Bills recap, key player stats (Tyreek Hill, Tua Tagovailoa, Josh Allen), drive-by-drive takeaways, standings impact and where to watch Miami Dolphins vs Buffalo Bills.

Quick result (TL;DR)

Final — Buffalo Bills 31, Miami Dolphins 21 (Thursday Night Football). Josh Allen threw three touchdown passes and James Cook rushed for 108 yards; Tua Tagovailoa threw two TDs (to Jaylen Waddle and Tyreek Hill) but a late interception by Terrel Bernard sealed the Bills’ victory. Miami drops to 0–3, Buffalo improves to 3–0.

Why this game mattered

Dolphins vs Bills is one of the NFL’s fieriest AFC East rivalries, and a prime-time slot only cranks up the stakes. For Miami, Week 3 was a must-start: the Dolphins needed a signature win to quiet the early-season noise and bounce back from two straight losses. Buffalo, 2–0 entering the night, wanted to keep pressure off their division and lean on Josh Allen’s momentum. The result sets the tone for the AFC East: the Bills look sharp, while the Dolphins face real questions about turnovers, penalties and finishing in close games.

Full game narrative — what happened (quarter-by-quarter)

First quarter — Dolphins jump early

Miami struck first as the Dolphins manufactured an early drive that ended in an Ollie Gordon II 2-yard touchdown run. The offense showed balance—enough rushing to open up passing lanes for Tua Tagovailoa. Buffalo answered quickly with a big 85-yard drive finished by Dalton Kincaid on a 20-yard catch. The tone was set: quick, explosive plays on both sides.

Second quarter — Bills pull ahead, Miami answers at the half

Josh Allen and Buffalo took over with a strike to Jackson Hawes for a touchdown before the end of the second quarter. Miami countered just before halftime with a Jaylen Waddle touchdown to tie the game 14–14 — a 16-play, 71-yard drive showing Miami’s ability to methodically move the ball. At halftime, it was a true shootout: 14–14.

Third quarter — Bills start taking control on the ground

The third quarter belonged to James Cook. He ripped off a grinding 2-yard touchdown after a sustained drive that gave Buffalo a 21–14 edge. Cook finished the night with 108 rushing yards — a significant workload that punished Miami’s defense and kept Tua off the field at critical stretches.

Fourth quarter — Tyreek ties it, but Bills answer and seal it

Miami stormed back: Tyreek Hill hauled in a 5-yard touchdown from Tua to tie the game 21–21 with 12:18 left in the fourth. But Miami’s special teams mistake — a costly roughing-the-kicker penalty on a punt — gave Buffalo life and better field position. Buffalo responded with a go-ahead TD to Khalil Shakir and Matt Prater later iced the game with a 48-yard field goal after a Tua interception by Terrel Bernard with under four minutes remaining. That pick ended Miami’s final chance.

The five load-bearing facts (most important, with sources)

1. Final score: Buffalo Bills 31, Miami Dolphins 21.
2. Josh Allen: Completed 22 of 28 passes for 213 yards and 3 TDs, driving Buffalo to a 3–0 start.
3. James Cook: Rushed for 108 yards and a touchdown, giving Buffalo balance and big-play strength on the ground.
4. Tua Tagovailoa: Finished 23/34 for 146 yards, 2 TDs and an interception — the late INT by Terrel Bernard ended a Miami comeback attempt.
5. Tyreek Hill: Caught 5 passes for 49 yards and 1 TD (the Dolphins’ late fourth-quarter score that tied the game at 21).

(These five statements are the most load-bearing game facts and are supported by Reuters, ESPN and NFL box-score reporting.)

Key player stats & box-score highlights

Buffalo Bills (standouts)

• Josh Allen (QB): 22/28, 213 yards, 3 TDs, 0 INTs. Efficient and timely, Allen avoided big mistakes and parceled the ball out to multiple targets.
• James Cook (RB): 108 rushing yards, 1 TD (2 yd). Cook’s consistent grind set the tone in the second half and forced Miami to defend the box.
• Khalil Shakir / Jackson Hawes (WRs): Big plays in the passing game — Hawes had a TD; Shakir caught the decisive score that put Buffalo ahead.
• Terrel Bernard (LB): Key interception late that sealed the Bills’ victory and swung momentum back after Miami tied the game.

Miami Dolphins (standouts)

• Tua Tagovailoa (QB): 23/34, 146 yards, 2 TD, 1 INT. Tua found Hill and Waddle for scores but the red-zone interception and pressure situations cost Miami late.
• Tyreek Hill (WR): 5 receptions, 49 yards, 1 TD. Hill’s touchdown tied the game late and represented his first TD of the season, but the Dolphins couldn’t convert that momentum into a win.
• Ollie Gordon II (RB): Scored Miami’s opening touchdown on a 2-yard rush and contributed in short-yardage situations.

For full team box scores, drives and play-by-play, see the ESPN/CBSSports box score pages.

In-game turning points & coaching decisions

1. Roughing the kicker penalty (Miami): A pivotal moment — Miami’s special teams committed a roughing the punter penalty that extended a Buffalo possession into the decisive go-ahead drive. As many analysts noted, special teams are often the difference in tight primetime games.
2. Terrel Bernard’s interception: With Miami pushing deep into Buffalo territory and trailing by seven, Bernard’s pick on Tua (with under 4 minutes left) ended Miami’s last realistic chance to tie or win. That turnover is the single most decisive play after Tyreek Hill’s tying TD.
3. James Cook’s running game: Buffalo’s decision to lean on Cook late opened the clock and limited Miami’s offensive possessions — a classic finish-game strategy that paid dividends.
4. Tua under pressure and misreads: Tua’s interception and earlier missed deep opportunities showed that Miami’s offensive timing and protection were not consistently clean enough to outgun Buffalo. Coaches will go back to tape to clean reps and pocket presence.

Tyreek Hill — performance, usage & fantasy takeaways

Tyreek Hill finished the night with 5 catches for 49 yards and a touchdown — a modest but critical stat line given the stage. Hill’s score came in the fourth quarter and was a highlight reel catch that tied the game at 21. Fantasy managers should note:

• Hill saw targets when Miami needed chunk plays — a positive usage sign.
• Yardage (49) is below his elite norms, reflecting Buffalo’s tough secondary and defensive gameplan. Over the season, expect Hill to be targeted on high-value opportunities even if total yards fluctuate.

For fantasy advice: Hill remains a weekly must-start in most formats due to TD upside, but monitor game scripts and matchup context.

Dolphins vs. Bills final score, immediate reactions: Buffalo holds on as Miami shows fight https://t.co/kPjLQUitm0

— The Phinsider (@thephinsider) September 19, 2025

X-and-O’s: Why Buffalo won and Miami fell short

Buffalo’s formula for victory

• Balance: Cook’s 108 rushing yards opened the playbook for Allen. When the defense stacks the box to stop the run, Allen’s playmaking becomes harder to stop. Conversely, when the run opens time on the perimeter, quick throws and YAC targets flourish.
• Limiting turnovers: Allen protected the ball (no interceptions) and delivered in the clutch — three TD passes and excellent accuracy (22/28) minimized Miami’s comeback windows.
• Capitalizing on penalties: Miami’s roughing the punter penalty was the kind of special-teams lapse Buffalo converted into points. Teams that win close games often avoid these mistakes; Buffalo did not.

Miami’s issues

• Turnovers at the worst time: The late interception was devastating. Miami moved the ball well at times but failed to protect possessions when they mattered most.
• Penalties and discipline: The roughing the kicker penalty extended a critical Buffalo drive. Small errors added up in a game decided by 10 points.
• Inability to sustain a pressure defense: Buffalo’s third-down conversions and time-of-possession advantages in the second half forced Miami to play catch up.

What this means for the AFC East & playoff picture

• Bills (3–0): Buffalo is off to an ideal start and look like legitimate AFC contenders early. A 3–0 start gives them a cushion in a competitive division and reinforces Josh Allen’s MVP-level argument.
• Dolphins (0–3): Miami’s 0–3 start is alarming; history shows falling behind early in a 17/18-game NFL season is recoverable, but internal questions (penalties, turnovers, depth against elite teams) must be resolved. The Dolphins will look to regroup before a pivotal Monday Night Football game vs the Jets later in the month.

Playoff implications are early, but prime-time losses can damage momentum and raise pressure on coaching staffs and quarterbacks — especially in a media market like Miami’s. The Bills’ victory strengthens their claim to be the AFC East team to beat right now.